Page 1 of 1

Sorabji Concerto

Posted: Thu May 26, 2022 1:51 pm
by Wilh3lm
Hello. I have once again returned with a Sorabji work. Today's offering is Concerto No. 5 published with a 1923 copyright date (under the name Concerto II).
Worldcat: https://www.worldcat.org/title/concerto ... /225365908

Re: Sorabji Concerto

Posted: Thu May 26, 2022 2:03 pm
by Sallen112
Go ahead.

Re: Sorabji Concerto

Posted: Thu May 26, 2022 2:11 pm
by Wilh3lm

Re: Sorabji Concerto

Posted: Sat May 28, 2022 7:23 am
by ahinton
We have an extensive list of corrections to this score, compiled by cellist and composer Mervyn Vicars and approved by the composer, although it is no doubt far from comprehensive; all of these early published Sorabji scores are error-ridden, some far worse than others and this is one of that tiny handful of them whose manuscript appears long since to have been lost (five of the others have suffered the same fate). There is also a copyist's copy of the solo piano part made at the composer's request for the work's dedicatee Alfred Cortot and annotated by the composer.

As much needed new typeset corrected editions of each of those early published scores are completed and issued, the demand for their original publications evaporates; we have noticed this ever since the first of them was produced quite a few years ago. So far, five of these have already been issued and five more are in various stages of preparation (although one of the latter was not originally published until 1931 in any case).

Re: Sorabji Concerto

Posted: Wed Jun 01, 2022 4:00 am
by Sallen112
ahinton wrote: Sat May 28, 2022 7:23 am We have an extensive list of corrections to this score, compiled by cellist and composer Mervyn Vicars and approved by the composer, although it is no doubt far from comprehensive; all of these early published Sorabji scores are error-ridden, some far worse than others and this is one of that tiny handful of them whose manuscript appears long since to have been lost (five of the others have suffered the same fate). There is also a copyist's copy of the solo piano part made at the composer's request for the work's dedicatee Alfred Cortot and annotated by the composer.

As much needed new typeset corrected editions of each of those early published scores are completed and issued, the demand for their original publications evaporates; we have noticed this ever since the first of them was produced quite a few years ago. So far, five of these have already been issued and five more are in various stages of preparation (although one of the latter was not originally published until 1931 in any case).
This is good info to add to the discussion page about the file under the gear icon on the workpage by creating a new topic.