IMSLP Forums

noqu - your typeset version of the clarinet part is an example of what I'm talking about. The star rating is supposed to be about the typesetting, not the editing, so it should be 5 stars as it is clean - no missing pages or blotches, no out-of-focus notes, and prints out correctly.

I have noticed that someone is going around giving one star to brand new editions typeset by the uploader which according to the guidelines should definitely be 5 stars. The latest one I noticed was Syrinx by Debussy. My suspicion is that this is someone set up by a commercial organisation. Has anyo...