IMSLP Forums

@steltz i have made a new edition based of the manuscript of the harpsichord concerto downloaded from imslp. so there is no (c) question here... and you didn't understand the problem i think. imslp list the violin concerto bwv 1056R with it's own work page. and my edition as a arrange/transcription ...

bwv 1059r ist just an arrangement based on a short fragment then it also shouldn't have it's own page and there is no proof that bwv 1056 ever was written for violin or oboe probably there is no lost original and to call them a reconstruction is actually completely wrong it's just wishful thinking l...

hi i uploaded a oboe concerto by bach yesterday. someone put it as a arrangement/transcription under the violin concerto bwv 1056r http://imslp.org/wiki/Violin_Concerto_in_G_minor,_BWV_1056R_%28Bach,_Johann_Sebastian%29 first it's not! it's a transcription from the harpsichord concerto bwv1056. (i'm...