IMSLP Forums

Many thanks, Cypressdome! Most interesting.

With all due respect, find a teacher who can clarify these issues for you. You obviously need help, and I doubt very much if you are going to find adequate solutions to your many technical problems on a forum.

I would be most interested to see these annotations, Cypressdome!

This is most helpful, kalliwoda! I do appreciate your efforts in clarifying this for me.

Many thanks,

stez

An interesting point, jossuk. I have contacted the Rheinberger Society in Liechtenstein but they have not deigned to respond. I will go with the Augener version (as I would have in any case), but was quite keen to clear up this anomaly. Thank you to all for the kind assistance.

stez

Thank you, coulonnus. A question: how does one edit one's posts? I have just noticed a small 'lapsus calami' when I referred to inverted comments rather than commas.

Many thanks for your efforts, coulonnus. I wonder if you could kindly explain your use of inverted comments around the word 'genuine'.

I wonder if any Rheinberger expert out there is able to clarify something for me. Having obtained the score from IMSLP files, I am now preparing this quite lovely quartet for performance and wonder why the third movement Menuetto in the downloaded version differs so markedly from the third movement ...