IMSLP Forums

I think these pages should be merged because there are the same duos


Greetings

Carmar

All done. A question, though: why does the first set seem to have two different opus numbers (6 and 29)? It's the same music...

Problems about Viotti and his opus number (like many others autors) are these:

Many editors (ancient) tried to pubblish opera omnia and all works were divided for instrument, so you can find string trios Op. 1 but there were others Op1:Sonatas for violin Op.1, String quartet Op.1 etc..
Others editors choose to put opus number in a progressive way so you can find string trios op 1 , string quartet op2 etc but other
editors started op 1 with sonatas for violin , op 2 with cello sonatas etc.. a very very big confusion.

For all about viotti I used the most common opus number (the first numbers), and a modern more scientific opus number (number in brachets).
The first way creates problem I told you.
The second way is not perfect : there are always new discoveries so it should be updated too.

I hope to have been exhaustive.

A question: Why the cake of the page is updated only when I'm logged?When I log out I can see only the old page.

Thank you for all
Greetings

Carmar

Thank you for the explanation. You have done a lot of work including the 'scientific' catalogues.
I think the old page was still visible because there was some kind of problem with double redirects. It should now work all right. If not, it shouldn't take more than a day or two to update.

Thank you for all

Greetings

Carmar