Page 1 of 1

Legrenzi Giovanni

Posted: Mon Dec 05, 2011 10:37 am
by Peterdyson49
18 Sonatas, Op.10 (Legrenzi, Giovanni)
The page title is incorrect: it should read Sonata No 18 Op 10.
Peter Dyson

Re: Legrenzi Giovanni

Posted: Wed Dec 07, 2011 8:44 pm
by Boccaccio
I think it is correct. There are 18 Sonatas in Op. 10 (can somebody confirm this?) out of which we happen to have only number 18, but others might follow at some point.

Re: Legrenzi Giovanni

Posted: Wed Dec 07, 2011 11:20 pm
by pierre.chepelov
I don't know − but I think you're right, Boccacio.
Why not using the proper title of the opus: La Cetra. Libro Quarto di Sonate a due tre e quattro stromenti?
BTW, we have an other Op.10 with Acclamationi Divote a voce sola, Libro Primo. I suspect this one could be Op.11 (This notice says "op. XI") and that the misnumbering comes from the Wikipedia lists...

Re: Legrenzi Giovanni

Posted: Thu Dec 08, 2011 6:00 am
by steltz
Grove Music's entry for op.10, listed under Instrumental, is:

"[16] La cetra, sonate a 2–4, libro quarto (Venice, 1673) [recte op.11], ed. S. Bonta (Cambridge, MA, 1992), no.13 and 4 ed. in HM, lxxxiii and lxxxiv (1951)"

and the entry for op.11, listed under Sacred (not Sacred Vocal), is:

"[2nd edn of op.10] (Venice, 1680), lost, see Sartori (1966); MS copy, I-Vnm".

My Latin isn't great, but "recte op.11" literally would mean "correctly op.11", which could be interpreted as a) it should have been numbered op.11, or b) the corrected version is op.11.

Anyone more familiar with Grove's use of this term want to weigh in?

Re: Legrenzi Giovanni

Posted: Thu Dec 08, 2011 7:35 am
by Notenschreiber
MGG (Musik in Geschichte und Gegenwart) says:

Acclamazioni divote a v. sola libro 1° op.10 (24 Mot.), Bologna 1670, Monti
La Cetra, libra 4° di sonate a 2-4 stromenti op.10 (sic! eigentlich op.11) 1673, Magni, Neudruck 1682
Cantate e Canzonette a v. sola op.12, Bologna 1676, Monti