Chorale Harmonisations, BWV 1-438 (Bach, Johann Sebastian)

[tox60]

This is actually C.P.E. Bach

[pml]

Would you perhaps like to identify which of the 40+ editions on that page is allegedly CPE’s work rather than JS’? Otherwise, posting something like this is fairly useless.

Thanks, PML

[Melodia]

IIRC, CPE Bach collected his father's chorales and had them published, and probably did editing, but he didn't actually compose any of them.

[pml]

That's my recollection as well – which is possibly the point of contention, but who can say from such a vague first post?

PML