Hi all,
for Händel's recorder sonata HWV 367a (https://imslp.org/wiki/Recorder_Sonata_ ... _Frideric)), piupianissimo uploaded two files (parts and complete score) back in 2015. One of them is accessible, the other is "pending review", according to the error page I go to when clicking the link. I am wondering if this is indeed true, and if so, would kindly request for this review to be finished, as I would like to get access to the score.
Thanks in advance for any info on this!
Best regards,
Jibbery Jeff
Score pending review for 10 years
Moderators: vinteuil, Leonard Vertighel, Lyle Neff, Wiki Admins
-
Jibbery Jeff
- Posts: 2
- Joined: Tue May 13, 2025 4:42 pm
- notabot: 42
- notabot2: Human
Re: Score pending review for 10 years
What do you mean this was "pending review for 10 years"? It looks like it was blocked back in March of this year because it was found the continuo part of the right hand is under copyright everywhere since it is a realization in the right hand. If the realization was completely redacted, we could have this available with only the left hand in the continuo part (and the recorder part) being shown.
Actually the "Complete Parts" file is basically the real "Urtext Edition" here (without figured bass included but you can add your own), not the score above it.
Actually the "Complete Parts" file is basically the real "Urtext Edition" here (without figured bass included but you can add your own), not the score above it.
-
Jibbery Jeff
- Posts: 2
- Joined: Tue May 13, 2025 4:42 pm
- notabot: 42
- notabot2: Human
Re: Score pending review for 10 years
Hi Sallen,
I was just going from the information I had available to me: I can see a publication date on the site which is 10 years in the past, and when I click the link, I get an error message stating the file is blocked pending review, additionally stating that all new files undergo this review (which to me implies that this is the case here).
Where and how can I find the additional information seemingly available to you?
It is quite unfortunate that the realization is the copyrighted part, as I, in fact, can not add my own (and I assume most amateur pianists in the world can not) but I guess then I'll have to buy a score with realization.
Thank you for taking a look and letting me know what's actually going on anyways!
I was just going from the information I had available to me: I can see a publication date on the site which is 10 years in the past, and when I click the link, I get an error message stating the file is blocked pending review, additionally stating that all new files undergo this review (which to me implies that this is the case here).
Where and how can I find the additional information seemingly available to you?
It is quite unfortunate that the realization is the copyrighted part, as I, in fact, can not add my own (and I assume most amateur pianists in the world can not) but I guess then I'll have to buy a score with realization.
Thank you for taking a look and letting me know what's actually going on anyways!