IMSLP Forums

People may have noticed the high number of "1"s received and low number of, well, any other rating.

Another user pointed out a possible bug with the rating system and I attempted to confirm it. Using Firefox 21 on my Mac with OS 10.7.5, I attempted to rate a recording of 3 movements of a quartet, I think it was, all 5s. What happened was, that after I refreshed my browser, the first movement that I'd rated had received three "1"s, and the other two movements I'd rated had not been affected at all.

I am not at all sure this is the intended behavior. Perhaps I could be set straight? Thanks!
Eric S.

It is exactly what I've also noticed several times. And I thought, it's my browser or whatever.
Ralph Theo Misch

See also this thread for a result similar to that of Eric's. I'm also running Firefox 21 but under Windows 7. I have, however, seen two of my submissions over the past week get a three star and a five star rating so it must still be possible for at least some users to leave some rating other than one or five.

Cypressdome

Ah - thanks!