Lully LWV 42 duplication
Posted: Fri Sep 17, 2010 7:56 am
It seems that the score IMSLP#31733 on work page http://imslp.org/wiki/Le_divertissement ... aptiste%29
and the score IMSLP#64510 on work page http://imslp.org/wiki/Ballet_les_Jeux_P ... aptiste%29
are actually the same work, score and scan (from BnF).
I'd suggest:
- a redirection from "Le divertissement royal" to "Ballet les Jeux Pithiens" (that, IMHO, should be renamed "Ballet Les Jeux Pithiens" to be coherent with the French capitalization rules - because "Les" is actually the first word of the title -, or "Ballet des Jeux Pithiens" to be coherent with the other "Ballets" on the composer page),
- the deletion of IMSLP#64510 (it lacks the first page (Philidor's ex-libris), and this generates a wrong pagination) and the retainment of IMSLP#31733.
and the score IMSLP#64510 on work page http://imslp.org/wiki/Ballet_les_Jeux_P ... aptiste%29
are actually the same work, score and scan (from BnF).
I'd suggest:
- a redirection from "Le divertissement royal" to "Ballet les Jeux Pithiens" (that, IMHO, should be renamed "Ballet Les Jeux Pithiens" to be coherent with the French capitalization rules - because "Les" is actually the first word of the title -, or "Ballet des Jeux Pithiens" to be coherent with the other "Ballets" on the composer page),
- the deletion of IMSLP#64510 (it lacks the first page (Philidor's ex-libris), and this generates a wrong pagination) and the retainment of IMSLP#31733.