New kind of genres

[The Messenger]

When I first came here I was looking for a all-genre music sheet site. Basicaly, a site where we can find from classical music sheets to pop music sheets. I haven't found a single one, so I decided to sugest one site in particular. Luckily for you, I chose your site, but I did not picked you randomly. I chose your site because, as you've said, "Our goal is to create a virtual library containing all public domain music scores". Please feel free to reply.

PS: Some of you may say that it is a stupid idea, but please try not to say that. I tolerate all opinions, so please accept mine.

[Melodia]

IMSLP accepts all genres last I checked. It's just that everything that's PD is still almost exclusively within the "classical music" sphere. You can't find, say, rock music on here because all rock music is still copyrighted.

[KGill]

Well, there are sites such as the California Sheet Music Project which have scans of 18th-century obscure American popular composers. Anyone is free to make a PDF from the raw images and upload it. And, of course, Joplin, PD Gershwin (worked for Tin Pan Alley, remember), etc. If anyone wants to contribute anything in those spheres, go for it

[vinteuil]

The problem is that most rock musicians don't want to publish their sheet music here (as most contemporary classical music composers don't either...).

[Lyle Neff]

The problem is that most rock musicians don't want to publish their sheet music here [...]

Lots of pop music is owned by publishers rather than by the song-writers. And we know how generous publishers are.

[The Messenger]

Well I was also thinking that people could also try to decode a music and write a music sheet down or use a software. People don't do that often but it is possible to do so.

[vinteuil]

It's still under copyright, so we still have to ask permission.

[The Messenger]

Also, there is no rock, pop, blues or hip-hop genre link. People may once in an while upload their own sheets with copylefts (opposite of copyrights), but they can't find one of those genres, or instruments.

[vinteuil]

If someone brings it up in the context of an upload, it will be taken care of. It has never happened before, however.

[The Messenger]

If someone brings it up in the context of an upload, it will be taken care of. It has never happened before, however.

It as never happened before because your site only as classical music. New people that want to upload new stuff won't know were to put it.

[vinteuil]

Look.
Let's assume that someone got all of the necessary permissions. Then, they decided to post it here of all places. Having gone through all that trouble, do you really think that they would not ask for new genres? We are not going to facilitate this, because the people who are going to or might be going to post other genres of music are going to ask, or be doing it illegally, in which case, they probably would stop having not seen the genres. We do not want to create superfluous categories that very well might never be used.

[Lyle Neff]

Also, there is no rock, pop, blues or hip-hop genre link.

By way of clarification, rock, pop, and hip-hop are styles of popular (or vernacular) music.

This is just another example of why the word "genre" is not helpful to this overall discussion (or in the "genre" portion of the IMSLP work submission form), because it is being employed to refer to everything from styles of music, to performance factors, to types of pieces.