LISZT Der nächtliche Zug

[Thomasdesi]

The Scan at http://imslp.org/wiki/2_Episoden_aus_Le ... zt,_Franz)
seems to me to have an issue: pp. 20 and 21 belong to a different piece of music. So pp 20. and 21 are MISSING actually from "der nächtliche Zug".
- td

[vinteuil]

Thanks for catching this—it's been noted on the work's page. In the future, please make such posts in the "work page issues" forum or similar, not "IMSLP Announcements."

[jossuk]

The two pages in question are apparently from the other episode, Der Tanz in der Dorfschenke (Mephisto Waltz No. 2). Whoever did the original scan may have stopped for a coffee break and lost track of which piece was in process.

[coulonnus]

Do you mean the Full Score, scanned by BSB (MDZ)? Did you ckeck the version on the BSB Site? I'm sure Piupianissimo will accept a remark if appropriate.

[jossuk]

I just visited the BSB site, and the same error (full score) exists in their copy. It now seems that either BSB mis-scanned, or the error was in the original publication. I'd be inclined toward the latter.

[Piupianissimo]

I've just scanned and uploaded the score. This one includes the correct pages 20 and 21. It seems like something went wrong at the scanning service at BSB, and I didn't check every page when I resized and uploaded them in 2010.

[jossuk]

Apparently it's being blocked for the moment; hopefully that will be resolved. Meanwhile, kudos for being willing to find a solution...!

[jossuk]

Just happened by on this thread from last year; unless I am mistaken, the error in the full score (pp.20-21) still exists...

[Piupianissimo]

I left the score from BSB with the missing pages untouched and added my own scan of the score which has all pages.
Just have a look at the first document named "1. Der nächtliche Zug (S.110/1) (scan)".

[jossuk]

I would have sworn that I checked that scan before commenting, but I see now that the pages are indeed as they should be. Thanks once again!